I have a copper coin that is the same size as an American half dollar and looks like an enlarged penny. I bought it years ago from a magic dealer who is now deceased. The problem is that it is not a very good likeness; Abe looks wrong, it says "Freedom" instead of "Liberty," and so on. It's cute, but.....

Meanwhile, I have two "pennies" that are as large as an Eisenhower silver dollar, and they look great.

Does anyone know where I can get good-looking half-dollar sized pennies?

That's a tough one...

Silver dollar sized american pennies are easy enough to find, but half dollar? Not so much.

Following this, because I want some as well!

The E Pluribus Orwell half dollar sized Lincoln Pennies don’t look too bad. But, they haven’t been available for decades. You’d probably have to find someone who would be willing to sell.

It occurred to me that the E Pluribus Orwell replica is actually a bit larger than a half dollar. So, if that’s important, finding something suitable might be near impossible.

Does it half to be a penny? There are a number of other custom coins - the Copeland Tiger/Tan coins come to mind - which are intentionally designed to be the exact same dimensions as the half dollar.

Have a look at https://en.numista.com/catalogue/index.php?ct=coin.
You can search for various criteria.

That's useful for finding real currency with specific dimensions but half and full dollar coins that look like US pennies aren't real currency so they won't be found there.

Thanks for all the replies, guys. I can keep using the one I have, but it looks sort of second-rate.

I was just hoping someone knew of a good source; years ago I went to a lecture by Jim Cellini, and he had a beaut.

Dishonest Abe by Gregory Wilson includes a serviceable half dollar size cent.

Good luck finding that, though. I believe it's out of print...