|
|
Go to page [Previous] 1~2 | ||||||||||
david_a_whitehead Inner circle USA 2122 Posts |
I will have to state my opinion here. I think nothing comes close to Books in terms of learning and honing and more learning. Darwin Ortiz, the great cardshark himself stated that Books are the ultimate reference. Videos are out there to complement books, not to replace them in any way. I watch a video and see a sleight and that is fine, but reading an expert book (eg. the expert at the card table, royal road, expert card technique, card college) has invaluable knowledge to learning sleights. I have seen a lot of videos explain (or semi explain) the pass but only after I read the complete works of derek dingle did my pass get any better. books are usually a lot more comprehensive on the subject at hand. Books are to be studied, videos are fun and should be a guide to presentation. I agree with loowhochan's comments. for a beginner a dvd might be the right way to start, but reading the sleight, then watching it being performed on video, then re-reading it again will get you so far. I am not here to state how anyone should learn. this was my path though, and I believe in it. I have bought dvds only to watch it maybe 2 or 3 times. then seldomly go back to them. I re-read my books so many times and use them so much more than videos. I wont be surprised if you all found you did the same thing. once again though, everyone is different. finanaceddragon stated his opinion...i did not find it very snobbish...it was just HIS opinion. and this is mine. If you feel you learn better differently then that is great for you.
|
|||||||||
joeKing Special user United States 979 Posts |
I agree, david...I find myself learning a tricks more "fully" when I learn them from a book rather than a video...
~joeKing
|
|||||||||
David Le Veteran user USA 365 Posts |
Tutorial videos from
http://e-magictrick.com are the best quality in my opinion......... but I guess that's because there the only ones I've seen! wait! I've seen three of McBrides from my friends collection. but that's card manip not card magic. you'll only love e-magic if you've been into prestigitial stuff for awhile. you'll learn the correct ways to do them and when you do, you'll be able to create your own card tricks. http://e-magictrick.com nobody does it better. and its free free........... if you are a magician |
|||||||||
erictan8888 Special user Singapore 517 Posts |
Ammar's ETMCM gets my vote...
daryl's video are also one of the best... eric
"Fill you life with magic by making magic a part of your life." by eric tan.
|
|||||||||
Turk Inner circle Portland, OR 3546 Posts |
Quote:
On 2003-11-23 03:02, financedragon wrote: I have to respectfully disagree with Financedragon when it comes to learning card moves ("developing your skills") as opposed to learning card tricks. For card tricks, books are great. But for tricky card moves detailing finger placements and the move itself, I find that video is much easier to learn from. A case in point: Steve Youell's two CDs on card moves are just about the best videos I have ever seen in explaining these difficult card moves (And they are cheap also). Steve not only shows you what to do, he also demonstrates what not to do and why certain things are critical to doing a move properly. Additionally, he shows the move and finger placements from multiple viewing angles. As you watch these moves being explained over and over and from different angles, a light bulb goes off in your head and you begin to undertand and appreciate the subtleties of the moves. It is just too difficult to explain these subtleties in text and with a few isolated hand drawings. (IMHO) Mike
Magic is a vanishing Art.
This must not be Kansas anymore, Toto. Eschew obfuscation. |
|||||||||
magicmanr Loyal user 226 Posts |
One nice thing about video/dvd is the fact that although some effects read dull, seeing them performed they are MUCH better than they read....
I own a multitude of dvds & videos, as well as an extensive library of books...Many of which compliment each other The only advantage to a book, IMO, is you have to be HANDS ON while reading it, to actually get any idea of the effect....Watching video, I (and I'm sure I'm not alone) have a tendency to just watch a performance, and say "Wow...that's great....I'll try that out sometime" instead of being hands on from the beginning... |
|||||||||
Hawky New user Montréal, Canada 51 Posts |
You can't go wrong with the Easy To Master Card Miracles seried by Ammar.
|