|
|
Jerrine![]() Special user Busking is work. 629 Posts ![]() |
I've found that the heat produced by such glues as Gorilla Glue weaken magnets. I want to permanently glue a magnet into wood. Anyone know of a glue that will hold metal and wood together without the heat?
|
Sam Pearce![]() Veteran user Ontario, Canada 309 Posts ![]() |
GOOP glue should work just fine.
Sam |
Spellbinder![]() Inner circle The Holy City of East Orange, NJ 6438 Posts ![]() |
I would be shocked if Gorilla glue can heat up enough to damage a permanent magnet any more than leaving a magnet out in the sun would. If the heat is really that intense, you can protect the magnet by surrounding it by a strong magnetic field using other magnets or an electromagnet while the glue dries, but I really can't believe you get any noticible loss of magnetism from such a small amount of heat. Are you going on hear-say or have you actually tested the magent's strength before and after?
Professor Spellbinder
Professor Emeritus at the Turkey Buzzard Academy of Magik, Witchcraft and Wizardry http://www.magicnook.com Publisher of The Wizards' Journals |
Jerrine![]() Special user Busking is work. 629 Posts ![]() |
Spellbinder, be shocked. Perhaps you misread the use of the word permanent. I want to permanently glue the magnet, not glue a permanent magnet. Stupid words, the order they are used matters.
![]() I'm not a hearsay fellow. I have glued magnets into various things and found that the strong glues that are used for multi-purpose use do weaken the magnets. I concluded without the benefit of scientific experiments that the heat from the glue weakened the magnet. It's possible that my hypothesis is incorrect and that some other factor has weakened the magnets, but weaker they are, considerably. Sam, you say should. Have you experience or is this an educated guess? |
JamesTong![]() Eternal Order Malaysia 11213 Posts ![]() |
I use craft glue or epoxy putty for permanently sticking the magnets on another surface materials. The craft glue I bought just say 'multi-purpose craft glue' and I really don't know the chemical name for it.
|
Jerrine![]() Special user Busking is work. 629 Posts ![]() |
Thank you James & Sam. For my current project I have found a better work-around but in the future I'm sure glue type will come up.
|
marty.sasaki![]() Inner circle 1117 Posts ![]() |
Can you toss the glue into a cooler to cool things down?
Marty Sasaki
Arlington, Massachusetts, USA Standard disclaimer: I'm just a hobbyist who enjoys occasionally mystifying friends and family, so my opinions should be viewed with this in mind. |
Jerrine![]() Special user Busking is work. 629 Posts ![]() |
I believe the heat is a reaction from the bonding process. Gorilla reacts with water to really get it going. The science behind it I am ignorant of. So I dunno if the heat is necessary for the glue to do it's thing, like say fire. Not a lot of cold fire around.
|
Cliffg37![]() Inner circle Long Beach, CA 2491 Posts ![]() |
The heat given off by Gorilla glue and many resins as they harden is the chemical reaction that changes the stuff from a liquid that is easily worked into a very hard gripping new chemical, or new form of the old chemical. I am intrigued by the idea of allowing it to react in a cooler. It will still give off its' heat, but will the magnet be less effected? That would be fun to test one day.
Magic is like Science,
Both are fun if you do it right! |
tbaer![]() Inner circle Pennsylvania 2006 Posts ![]() |
|
leapinglizards![]() Inner circle 1263 Posts ![]() |
Also occurs to me that for Guerilla glue to work you have to CLAMP the items very tightly... If you are doing this, it could be the clamping that is the issue.
Leaping Lizards!!! Who knew it was possible.
<BR> <BR>www.LeapingLizardsMagic.com |
Magical Dimensions![]() Inner circle 5001 Posts ![]() |
Quote:
On 2007-09-27 21:44, leapinglizards wrote: If you have to clamp the item with something like a C-clamp then why not just use Elmers white glue? |
Dr. Solar![]() Special user Citrus Heights, Ca. 526 Posts ![]() |
Any 5 minute epoxy, sold in A&B tubes will work very good.
Dr. solar
"look for me in all things forgotten"
www.drsolar.com |
JamesTong![]() Eternal Order Malaysia 11213 Posts ![]() |
Quote:
On 2007-09-27 19:12, Cliffg37 wrote: I have not thought about the idea of using the cooler. I'll try that one day and see whether the magnet is affected in any measurable way. |
Zazz![]() Veteran user California 315 Posts ![]() |
I've use a double sided tape to hold magnets to wood. The ultra thin type that is used to adhere plastic labels to machinery or electrical cabinets. This tape is very strong. It is borderline permanent.
Dan |
Dave V![]() Inner circle Las Vegas, NV 4824 Posts ![]() |
NEO magnets can lose their magnetism at a relatively low 170 degrees.
Cooling might protect the magnet, but I'd be prepared for the glue to not set up for a very long time. If heat is part of the curing process, lack of heat will likely mess up that process.
No trees were killed in the making of this message, but a large number of electrons were terribly inconvenienced.
|
Michael Baker Eternal Order Near a river in the Midwest 11172 Posts ![]() |
You mention gluing the magnet INTO wood, as opposed to ON wood. I have glued many small neo magnets into recesses using a gel CA, plus accellerant. With a reasonably well-sized recess, fitting the magnet very closely, the glue adheres to the bottom and all sides, creating a bond that is difficult to break without the shock of impact. The force required to break the bond is greater than the force require to cause the magnet to separate from its magnetic mate.
When I was somewhat more concerned about a non-breakable bond, I have countersunk the magnets from the opposite side of the work. A Forstner bit is used to drill a hole to such a depth as to leave just a veneer's thickness. The magnet, if sufficiently strong, will have the holding strength to overcome the very slight distance between it and its magnetic mate. Regarding AB epoxys... it has been my experience that the faster the set, the greater heat generated. Thickness of the glue layer is also a factor. I have poured 5 minute epoxy, using it as one would polyester resin, and had it heat up so much as to literally burn to an amber color, and be so hot that you could not touch it. PC-7 exopy paste is a very slow setting brand (about 24 hrs) that may work. I have not noticed significant heat generated during the cure. It is very effective for adhering to wood and metal, as well as other materials (some plastics, not so good).
~michael baker
The Magic Company |